Are you sure you want to leave?

Your test is still in progress. If you leave this page or go back now, all your attempt wil not be saved.

The Tang family are planning a day out tomorrow. They will decide where to go based on the weather in the morning. There are three possibilities:
  • If it’s sunny in the morning, they’ll visit their aunt who lives by the beach.
  • If it’s raining, they’ll go to the indoor market to do some shopping.
  • If it’s overcast but not raining, they will head into town. They might still go to the indoor market but they definitely won’t go to the beach.
The weather forecast for tomorrow morning is for sunshine.
 

Victor: “If you see the Tangs in the indoor market tomorrow, it must mean it’s been raining.”

Aidan: “If you see them at the beach, it must mean the weather forecast was correct.”

If the information in the box is true, whose reasoning is correct?