Are you sure you want to leave?

Your test is still in progress. If you leave this page or go back now, all your attempt wil not be saved.

The Hunter Valley region generates most of its income from its wineries. In the past two years, the wineries in the region have suffered a drastic decrease in income. This reduction in income coincided with a campaign by the local Health Minister who has warned the public against adverse health effects from excessive alcohol consumption.

 

Andrew: “The local health minister is responsible for the reduction of income in the Hunter Valley."

 

Mikki: “Warning the public against the negative effects of drinking alcohol must be effective.”

If the information in the box is true, whose reasoning is correct?